With 13 pizzerias, there's plenty to choose from and a pie for everyone's taste buds.
While we get ready to announce a winner next week (the plaque engraver is at work right now), we thought it would be a good time to summarize and share some of our personal experiences. This taste journey started way back in February, and from there to here it's been a cheesy, saucy trip. We have officially sampled the plain pizza offerings of each of the 13 pizzerias in The Caldwells and emerged wiser ... and perhaps, fatter. General Pizza Taste Chart In The Caldwells, who has more of a cheesy, saucy and somewhere in between pizza? Based on our tests, and in no particular order: More of a "Cheesy" Pie: Pizza and Sandwich Barn, Frank's Trattoria and Domino's More of a Sauce Pie: Nicco's and Calandra's Somewhere In Between: Forte, Russillo…
40.83635
-74.271591
Forte Pizzeria & Ristorante
182 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
49813
/locations/417006
40.837455
-74.273056
Calandra's Italian Village
234 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
50458
/locations/417007
40.85164
-74.294369
40 Clinton Rd, West Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
/locations/417008
40.851889
-74.300199
Franco's Ristorante & Pizzeria
907 Bloomfield Ave, West Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
49804
/locations/417009
40.839127
-74.275239
Cedar Grill & Pizza
295 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
50003
/locations/417010
40.838645
-74.274592
Nicco's Italian Deli & Specialties
275 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
49416
/locations/417011
40.839697
-74.276004
Pizza & Sandwich Barn
323 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
49432
/locations/417012
40.84117
-74.27891
Domino's Pizza
399 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
49812
/locations/417013
40.84234
-74.28076
455 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
/locations/417014
40.848094
-74.290958
Michael's Pizzeria & Restaurant
669 Bloomfield Ave, West Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
49242
/locations/417015
40.84825
-74.291111
Russillo Ristorante & Pizzeria
675 Bloomfield Ave, West Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
49449
/locations/417016
40.850378
-74.295777
Frank's Trattoria
802 Bloomfield Ave, West Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-of-the-caldwells-contest-a-review
49814
/locations/417017
National franchises draw split decision on night of Papa John's grand opening.
This week, we're presenting a contest within a contest. Instead of stopping in at just one pizzeria, we checked out both Domino's (399 Bloomfield Ave., Caldwell) and Papa John's, which held its grand opening Thursday night at 455 Bloomfield Ave., in Caldwell on the corner of Central Avenue. How will the local branches of these national franchises fare against each other, and the local businesses of The Caldwells overall? We can't wait to tell you, but let's take a look at the world of pizza franchising first. Background In case you haven't been paying attention, the "chain" pizza wars have been heating up as of late. There was a time when Domino's ruled the Northeast in fast-food pizza takeout. The local spot on Bloomfield Avenue in …
40.84234
-74.28076
455 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-contest-dominos-or-papa-johns
/locations/335810
40.84117
-74.27891
Domino's Pizza
399 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell, NJ
/articles/best-pizza-contest-dominos-or-papa-johns
49812
/locations/335811
Chris Ringgold
6:36 am on Tuesday, January 25, 2011
We prefer to give our biz to the local restaurants. We order with Eat24hours and we get cash back. One of the best, two thumbs up!   more ›